After Toby (Jack Bailey) loses his virginity to his dad's best friend Carl (Dale Savage), Toby wants something serious with the older man. Unfortunately for Toby, Carl wanted a virgin, and now that Toby isn't one, Carl is not interested. That is, until Toby's father calls Carl to tell him that Toby and his best friend Will (Scott Finn) will be in Carl's town and they need a place to stay. Hearing that Will is coming with Carl gives Carl a bright idea. He opens his home to Toby and Will, and Toby will do whatever it takes to get back in Carl's good graces.